ISO TC 184/SC 4/WG 3/T 23 (SHIP TEAM) Minutes
Theme: Preliminary
Ballot Review for AP 218 and 215
4th– 7thNovember 2002,
·
Koji Kawamura Japan
·
Masaaki Kamei Japan
·
Jong Kap Lee Korea
·
Dong Kon Lee Korea
·
Gerry Radack USA
·
Ron Wood
USA
·
Burton Gischner USA
·
Tatsuya Sakuma Japan
·
Hiroyuki Kakuno Japan
·
Chan-Cook Park Korea
·
Piek Jenssen Norway
·
Paul van Exel Netherlands
·
John Kendall (chair) UK
·
Tim Turner UK
·
Magne Valen-Sendstad Norway
John Kendall opened the meeting. T23
acronyms are in Annex A. The agenda in
Annex R was approved and the Opening Plenary report is in Annex S.
A status of the K-STEP project was given by Dr. Kim. See Annex D for the presentation.
Ron Wood gave an update of the status of
E-STEP, it included a summary of their recent year 2 demonstration and the
details of their next year 3 demonstration.
The fuller details will be given at the tutorial later in the week. See
Annex E for details.
See action list Annex C.
-
250 US Comments
US 203 editorial
not technical
It was decided to defer
resolution of the issues until the workshop in January due to the lack of
appropriate expertise at the meeting.
See Annex I for the list of these issues. These are preliminary issue and have not been approved by US-TAG
yet.
ATS318 is up for cancellation currently at
20.00 for 100+ months. The document at
the moment consists of only test data.
The meeting discussed the need and effort
required for the ATS and decided that the more informal approach of producing a
usage guide and test cases was a better approach.
Therefore instead of producing an ATS KSTEP
will produce test cases with a usage guide using AP227 usage guide as a
template. There was no opposition from
the meeting for ATS 318 being cancelled; accordingly GR will draft the last day
resolution.
AP214 has over 200 SEDS issues.
AP203 ed2 is adding the ability to compute
cog, including PDM modules, csg, geometric presentation, materials, and
geometric tolerancing.
AP234 has been cancelled under the 3 year
rule. There is an option is to restart
with a NWI. However it would be better
to use AP227 and RDL. Need to investigate
how much work it is to add lifecycle phase to AP227. PLCS will be looked at as well.
DNV will investigate and come back with
recommendations.
The open technical forum topic was
‘Referencing RDLs from APs’ which is of relevance for the AP227/ISO 15926 work
being done within T23. Presentations
were given by
A joint session between T23 and T24
Purpose: We need to agree on an action plan
for what needs to be done between this and the next meeting to determine how we
can get AP227/ISO15926 to replace AP226 as this still isn’t clear.
Mr Lee from Kriso gave a presentation on the
work done on the e-commerce for ship building project. See Annex F for details.
There is currently no data exchange between
shipyards, but there is a move to unify the structural and outfitting CAD systems. Samsung on GSCAD, Daewoo on TIBON M2,
Hyundai are currently looking to replace their current CAD systems (Autokon,
CADDS, TRIBON), a decision will be taken by the end of the year.
KS-STEP will continue to develop the test
cases for STEP APs and provide the motivation for industry.
Magne gave a presentation on the work done
by DNV on putting the test case into ISO 15926
See Annex G for details.
Some of the functionality covered by ISO15926
is also covered by 227, there needs to be work done where the information is
covered and a gap analysis on what information is not covered.
The data was put into an excel spreadsheet
(See Annex H)
DNV will use ISO 15926 as their internal
database and want STEP APs to cover all the data exchange requirements; this
means that AP227 will have to be capable of transferring all the data which can
be represented in the RDL.
TJT gave a presentation on how the test data
has been covered in AP227 (See Annex J)
ACTIONS:
1. Tim to provide new ARM entities to EMSA for review
and then provide to Rob. (Dec 6)
2. Tim to re-evaluate modeling “connections”
3. Confirm with EMSA on changes at meeting in February
See attached Gantt chart for full details of
the development schedule (Annex Q).
Friedrich Glantschnig
Peter Mueller
Chiaki Sakamoto
Masahara Tsuchiya
David Laffredo
Yong Tak Hyun
Olaf Nyqvist
Alan Crawford
Carol Tierney
Yong-Dae Kim
Kwang-Phil Park
William Gruttke
Meinolf Groper
Len Slovensky
Takeshi Kishinami
Dave Loffredo of STEP Tools presentation
Presented 2
See Annex K for details
Koji Kawamura (ECOM): slide on AP227 ed 2
changes (see Annexes L and M for details)
Len Slovenski reviewed AP240? ARM EXPRESS G
contents (process planning) See annex N.
Good synergy between T-24 and T-23 - Make
slot on Next ISO Thursday
The work of T23 this week was presented to
the WG3 plenary.
See Annex O for presentation.
See Annex P for Agenda for San Diego.
The T23 resolutions canceling ATS318 and
AP226 were both passed by SC4.